Hiring today looks a lot different than it did a decade ago. With the rise of gig work and temp staffing agencies, businesses have more flexibility than ever to scale their workforce. Need extra hands for peak season? No problem. Looking for specialized skills on a short-term basis? There’s a staffing agency for that.

It’s no surprise that 37% of Canadian businesses rely on gig workers, and Ontario alone has over 2,200 temp agencies supplying thousands of workers. On the surface, it seems like a win-win: companies get the workers they need without the long-term commitment, and workers gain more job opportunities.

But there’s a big catch—compliance risk.

Just because you’re hiring through a third party doesn’t mean you’re off the hook legally. If a staffing agency or gig platform isn’t playing by the rules, your business could be the one paying the price. And we’re not talking about small mistakes.

The misclassification of gig workers as independent contractors has been such a problem that the federal government tightened labour laws in 2023 under the Canada Labour Code to crack down on it.

For businesses, a compliance slip-up can mean fines, back payments, a damaged reputation, or even losing a chunk of your workforce overnight. Not exactly the kind of surprise any employer wants.

The Role of Vendor Compliance Audits

So how do you protect your business? By auditing your staffing vendors before problems arise.

A vendor compliance audit is essentially a check-up for your third-party staffing providers. It ensures they’re following all the necessary laws and best practices—covering things like:

• Licensing & Insurance – Are they legally authorized to operate?
• Payroll & Worker Classification – Are they paying employees properly and classifying them correctly?
• Workplace Safety & Compliance – Are workers being provided with a safe work environment?

Think of it as trust, but verify—because assuming everything is in order could end up being a costly mistake.

In the next section, we’ll break down a five-step process for conducting vendor compliance audits in Canada. Let’s begin

Step 1: Legal & Regulatory Review

Before working with any staffing vendor, employers need to ensure that they meet all legal and regulatory requirements. This involves verifying their licensing, insurance coverage, and compliance with workplace safety laws.

Licensing and Registration

One of the first things to check is whether the staffing agency or contractor is legally registered to operate. Regulations vary by province, and some jurisdictions have introduced stricter rules. For example, Ontario now requires all temporary help agencies to hold a provincial license, and from July 1, 2024, businesses are prohibited from engaging with unlicensed agencies. Failing to comply could result in steep fines—up to $50,000 for repeat violations.

Rather than taking a vendor’s word for it, always request official documentation or verify their license through government registries. A reputable staffing agency will have no problem providing proof of compliance.

Workers’ Compensation Coverage (WSIB/WCB)

If a staffing agency supplies workers, it is critical to confirm they are covered by workers’ compensation insurance. In Ontario, for instance, employers should request a WSIB clearance certificate to ensure that the agency is up to date with premium payments. Each province has its own workers’ compensation board (WCB), so employers must check that their vendor is enrolled in the appropriate program.

Without proper coverage, businesses may find themselves liable for workplace injuries, which can result in costly compensation claims. This simple verification step can help employers avoid significant financial risk.

Occupational Health & Safety Compliance

Gig and temp workers have the same rights to a safe workplace as full-time employees. Employers cannot assume that safety obligations are solely the responsibility of the staffing agency.

When conducting a compliance audit, ask the vendor about their health and safety training procedures. Are workers equipped with the necessary protective gear? Do they have up-to-date safety certifications, such as WHMIS or first aid? Vendors should be able to provide proof that their workers receive proper training before being placed in a work environment.

Employers must also ensure that vendor-supplied workers participate in on-site safety briefings and drills. Failing to maintain a safe working environment can result in legal consequences and reputational damage.

Step 2: Financial & Payroll Compliance Check

Even if a staffing agency handles payroll, your business can still be held responsible if things go wrong. Wage violations, worker misclassification, or tax compliance issues don’t just affect workers—they can lead to serious financial and legal trouble for your company, too. That’s why double-checking payroll compliance should be a key part of any vendor audit.

Fair Wages and Benefits: 

Just because a staffing agency is in charge of payroll doesn’t mean you should assume everything is above board. Workers need to be paid at least according to provincial employment standards—including minimum wage, overtime, and holiday pay. Unfortunately, some agencies take advantage of workers by underpaying them or skipping legally required benefits.

A recent government inspection uncovered millions of dollars in unpaid wages, including vacation and holiday pay. To avoid being tied to wage violations, businesses should request sample pay stubs (with personal details redacted) or written confirmation that workers are paid fairly and receive proper benefits.

Worker Classification: 

One of the biggest compliance risks in today’s gig economy is worker misclassification. Some staffing agencies label workers as independent contractors to sidestep taxes and benefits, but if those workers function like full-time employees, this can lead to major legal trouble.

If the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) determines a worker was misclassified, both the employer and the staffing agency could be forced to pay back payroll taxes, benefits, and penalties. That’s why it’s crucial to review how vendors classify workers and make sure your contracts include clauses that protect your business from misclassification claims.

Payroll Taxes: 

A compliant staffing vendor should be remitting payroll taxes properly—this includes income tax, EI, and CPP deductions. The problem? If they don’t do it correctly, your business could end up being held responsible for unpaid taxes.

To protect yourself, request proof that the vendor is registered for payroll remittances and confirm they have no outstanding tax liabilities. A quick verification now can save you from expensive problems later.

Step 3: Risk & Audit Compliance

When working with staffing vendors, it’s not just about payroll and licensing—you also need to assess potential risks. Are they reliable? Do they follow industry regulations? Have they had compliance issues in the past? Taking the time to evaluate these factors helps protect your business from legal trouble, financial losses, and operational disruptions.

Vendor Risk Assessment

Choosing the right staffing vendor isn’t just about finding someone who can fill positions—it’s about making sure they’re reliable, compliant, and won’t cause problems down the line. A little research upfront can save you from major headaches later. Here’s what to check:

• Legal History: Before signing anything, take a look at their track record. Have they been involved in lawsuits, compliance violations, or disputes with past clients? If a vendor has a history of legal trouble, it could mean issues with payroll, worker treatment, or failing to meet labor laws—all things you don’t want to deal with.
• Client Feedback: One of the best ways to vet a vendor is by talking to businesses that have worked with them. Were they reliable? Easy to communicate with? Did they follow through on compliance requirements? If past clients had issues, chances are you might, too.
• Public Records: Do a quick search to see if they’ve ever been flagged for wage disputes, employment violations, or safety infractions. If they’ve got a pattern of cutting corners, that’s a sign they might not be the right fit for your business.

Insurance and Liability Coverage

A trustworthy staffing agency should have solid insurance coverage to protect both your business and their workers. This includes general liability, professional liability, and workers' compensation insurance—all essential in case of accidents, payroll disputes, or legal claims. Before moving forward, ask for a Certificate of Insurance (COI) and verify that their coverage aligns with industry standards. If a workplace injury happens or there’s a payroll mistake, you want to be sure your business isn’t the one paying the price.

Fraud Prevention and Ethical Conduct

Payroll fraud, inflated invoices, or sketchy hiring practices can lead to serious financial and reputational damage. The best way to stay ahead of potential fraud is by regularly auditing invoices and timesheets to catch red flags like overbilling or ghost employees—workers who exist on paper but never actually show up. Setting clear expectations with vendors, ensuring transparency in billing, and having a structured review process in place help prevent mismanagement and unethical practices before they become bigger issues.

Step 4: Contract & Policy Review

Once you’ve confirmed that a vendor meets compliance standards, the next step is to make it official. A contract isn’t just a payment agreement—it’s a legal safeguard that enforces compliance, protects your business, and ensures everyone is on the same page.

A handshake or verbal agreement won’t cut it when it comes to legal and financial liability. If a vendor fails to pay workers properly, violates labor laws, or doesn’t follow industry regulations, your business could be on the hook for lawsuits, penalties, or reputational damage. A well-drafted contract clearly defines expectations, responsibilities, and consequences—reducing the risk of compliance failures.

Why a Strong Contract Matters

A contract is more than just paperwork—it’s your safety net. It sets clear expectations, holds staffing vendors accountable, and ensures they operate within legal and ethical guidelines. A well-structured agreement prevents misunderstandings and protects your business from unnecessary risks.

Key Elements to Include in Your Compliance Contract:

Here’s what every compliance contract should cover to ensure vendors meet their obligations:

• Compliance Clauses: Vendors must follow all applicable labor laws, including wage regulations, workplace safety standards, and employment rights. This not only keeps your business legally protected but also ensures fair treatment of workers, reducing the risk of labor disputes.
  
  
• Right to Audit: Employers should have the right to review payroll and safety records at any time. Regular audits help catch inconsistencies, ensure proper wage payments, and verify compliance with workplace regulations. Having this in writing allows you to step in before small issues turn into big problems.
  
  
• Indemnification Provisions: If a vendor’s non-compliance leads to fines, penalties, or lawsuits, they should be responsible for covering the costs. This clause ensures your business isn’t left paying the price for mistakes you didn’t make, whether it’s due to improper payroll handling or failure to meet industry regulations.
  
  
• Workplace Policies: Vendors should align with your company’s safety protocols, conduct policies, and confidentiality agreements to maintain a consistent work environment. This includes everything from preventing workplace harassment to safeguarding sensitive business information. Setting these expectations upfront minimizes conflicts and ensures smooth collaboration.
  
  

A well-structured contract makes expectations crystal clear, reduces risk, and keeps vendors accountable. It’s always easier to prevent issues with a solid agreement than to fix problems later!

Step 5: Automating Compliance Tracking for Ongoing Monitoring

By now, it’s clear that managing vendor compliance is an ongoing process—full of deadlines, document updates, and legal requirements. Trying to keep up manually, whether through spreadsheets or email reminders, can quickly become overwhelming—especially if you’re juggling multiple staffing providers and gig workers.

The final step to ensuring long-term compliance is automation. Instead of scrambling when something goes wrong, an automated system keeps everything up to date in real-time, reducing human error, preventing compliance lapses, and eliminating last-minute document scrambles.

Never Miss a Renewal Again

Tracking renewal dates manually is a hectic task—one missed deadline can lead to compliance issues, penalties, or even work stoppages. With automated alerts, you get notified well in advance before licenses, certifications, or insurance policies expire. This gives you plenty of time to renew or follow up with vendors before it becomes a problem. No more last-minute scrambles or chasing down documents at the eleventh hour.

Get a Real-Time Snapshot of Compliance Status

Trying to track vendor compliance through spreadsheets and emails is exhausting and inefficient. Automation gives you a clear, real-time dashboard where you can instantly see which vendors are compliant and which ones need attention. Instead of wasting time digging through emails or manually updating files, you have all the information at your fingertips—making compliance management faster and stress-free.

Instant, Accurate Reports for Audits & Reviews

Preparing for an audit or regulatory review can take hours—or even days—if you have to compile data manually. Automation eliminates this hassle by generating compliance reports in seconds. Whether you need a list of active contractors, proof of work permits, or WSIB clearance statuses, you can pull up the information instantly with just a few clicks. No more scrambling to gather paperwork at the last minute.

Keep a Secure Digital Audit Trail

When compliance is handled manually, things can easily slip through the cracks—documents get misplaced, updates don’t get recorded, and there’s no clear history of actions taken. Automation logs every compliance action automatically, creating a reliable audit trail. Every update, document submission, or status change is recorded, ensuring full transparency and accountability. If there’s ever a compliance issue, you have a clear record to refer back to—eliminating confusion and reducing risk.

When businesses use technology to stay on top of compliance, they save time, reduce admin headaches, and ensure nothing falls through the cracks. Why do it the hard way when automation can do it for you?

Tired of Chasing Compliance Documents? VRFI Has You Covered.

Ever feel like vendor compliance is just a never-ending checklist—licenses, insurance, work permits, safety reports—spread across emails, spreadsheets, and folders? It’s a lot to keep up with, but it doesn’t have to be a headache.

VRFI provides all-in-one staffing solutions and acts as your compliance manager too, keeping all your staffing vendor and gig worker documentation in check, so you can focus on running your business instead of chasing paperwork.

Here’s how VRFI helps Canadian employers stay compliant effortlessly:

All Your Compliance Data in One Place

No more sifting through files or digging through emails. VRFI’s dashboard gives you a real-time view of every vendor’s compliance status—license renewals, insurance coverage, and required documents—all in one place. Green checks mean you’re in the clear, and missing items are flagged so you can take action before they become a problem.

Automated Worker Verification

Manually checking documents? That’s a thing of the past. VRFI automatically verifies payroll records, tax forms, work permits, and certifications. Whether you need to confirm an agency has remitted EI/CPP or check a contractor’s WHMIS training, VRFI gives you instant verification and keeps a seamless digital record.

Never Miss a Deadline

Compliance deadlines have a way of sneaking up, but VRFI ensures nothing slips through the cracks. Automated alerts notify you before key documents expire—whether it’s an agency contract, a safety compliance report, or a worker’s permit—so you can stay ahead of the game.

Fast, Accurate Compliance Reports

Need compliance data for an audit, a board meeting, or a government review? VRFI delivers reports in seconds. Pull up lists of active contractors, work permits, or WSIB clearance statuses instantly, saving time and ensuring accuracy.

Seamless Vendor Communication

Skip the endless email chains. With VRFI, you can request updates and upload documents directly within the platform—keeping everything logged, clear, and accountable.

Why VRFI?

VRFI simplifies compliance, taking the stress out of audits, document tracking, and worker verification. Designed for Canadian employers navigating complex regulations, it ensures peace of mind—so you can focus on growing your business instead of chasing compliance deadlines.

Vendor Compliance: A Smarter Way to Build a Stronger Workforce

Vendor compliance isn’t just about avoiding penalties—it’s about creating a fair, transparent, and efficient workplace where everyone thrives. When businesses stay ahead of compliance:

• Workers feel valued. Fair pay and proper treatment lead to higher motivation, better performance, and smoother operations.
• Trust is built. When vendors and workers see you’re on top of compliance, accountability improves, and risks decrease.
• Technology does the heavy lifting. With automation, you eliminate manual tracking, missed deadlines, and last-minute scrambles.

Think of compliance as more than just a legal must-have—it’s a strategic advantage that strengthens your workforce, protects your business, and keeps everything running seamlessly.

VRFI makes it easy. From real-time tracking to automated reminders, it ensures you stay compliant without the stress.

Why juggle compliance when you can master it? See how VRFI can help you stay ahead—without the headaches.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a vendor compliance audit, and why does it matter?

A vendor compliance audit is like a background check for your staffing agency. It helps ensure they’re following the right legal and payroll practices—things like proper worker classification, fair wages, and workplace safety. If your vendor isn’t playing by the rules, your business could face fines, legal trouble, or even end up responsible for unpaid wages. Regular audits help you avoid these risks and keep everything running smoothly.

2. How can I make sure a staffing agency is legally compliant before working with them?

Before signing anything, ask for proof of licensing, insurance, and compliance with employment laws. Some provinces, like Ontario, even require staffing agencies to hold a license. Also, check if they have proper worker compensation coverage. A good agency will have no problem sharing these details—if they hesitate, that’s a red flag.

3. What happens if I don’t check a staffing agency’s compliance?

Ignoring compliance can be costly. If a staffing agency fails to pay workers properly, misclassifies them, or skips payroll taxes, your business could be on the hook for fines, back payments, or even legal disputes. Plus, non-compliance issues can damage your reputation and disrupt operations—imagine suddenly losing a chunk of your workforce because an agency was shut down for violations.

4. How do I protect my business from staffing agency fraud?

Fraud can happen through overbilling, ghost employees (workers who don’t exist but are on payroll), or falsified time sheets. To protect yourself, regularly audit invoices, cross-check worker hours with actual shifts, and ensure your contracts allow for financial transparency. A reliable staffing agency will have solid record-keeping and won’t hesitate to provide proof of payments.